MENA Open Data & Evidence Lab
Open Review Assignments

Do one piece of work that changes a release state.

The Lab is not recruiting decorative contributors. These are bounded external verification assignments tied to specific research objects. A completed assignment creates an attributable review record and, where the evidence standard is met, changes the validation state of that release.

Source audit

Official Price Release Observatory v0.3.0-rc1

Independently inspect one official release from each of five institutions, compare source capture and transformations, include the specified conflict-affected Palestinian pair, and document discrepancies before any repair.

Evidence returned

Completed audit template, source links checked, discrepancies, environment or process notes, attribution consent.

OPEN
Second coding

MENA AI Adoption & Labor Adjustment

Code the frozen validation sample independently without seeing founder labels, then compare results only after submission.

Evidence returned

Completed coding file, agreement statistics, disagreement log, attribution consent.

OPEN
Process audit

MENA Funding & Procurement Intelligence

Audit a bounded sample of official-source ingestion, normalization and classification decisions and report any disagreements or coverage gaps.

Evidence returned

Sample audit sheet, source comparison, disagreement log, limitations note.

OPEN
Reproduction

Workshop 001

After live delivery, use only the public package in a clean environment to recover the published teaching outputs and log any friction or divergence.

Evidence returned

Reproduction log, environment, recovered outputs, discrepancies.

OPENS AFTER DELIVERY
Boundary: completing an assignment does not automatically make someone an advisor, co-author or institutional partner. Those are separate relationships with separate acceptance and authorship rules.
Review protocol

What makes an external review count.

01 / IDENTIFIABLE

A real person completes the work and can be attributed in the review record unless a documented safety reason requires limited public identification.

02 / INDEPENDENT

The reviewer is not the primary producer of the object being validated and relevant conflicts are disclosed.

03 / REVIEWABLE

The work leaves an artifact: audit sheet, coding file, reproduction log, discrepancy record or methods memorandum.

04 / STATE-CHANGING

The result maps to a defined validation field. Informal praise and private comments do not change release status.

Recognition

Accepted work records the contributor, contribution type, affected artifact, date and evidence location. Authorship follows documented intellectual contribution; review alone is not authorship. Advisory appointment is also separate and is listed only after explicit acceptance.

Working materials

Reviewers can use the bounded task specification, reviewer packet, validation dashboard and machine-readable assignment register. Open a repository issue before substantial work so scope and evidence requirements are frozen before review begins.

Advisory appointments

Methods & Reproducibility, Regional Data, and Open Research & Governance remain open advisory roles. They are not used as substitute evidence for release-level review.